13930 WA-9, Arlington, WA 98223
Leave your details, we will be in touch
Will My Insurance Policy Cover My Sewage BackUp? What Homeowners Need to Know
If sewage has ever backed up into your home, you already know how overwhelming it can be.
The smell, the mess, the disruption. And almost immediately, one question comes up:
Will my insurance policy cover this?
The honest answer is: sometimes.
Whether insurance pays or denies always comes down to why the backup happened.
The smell, the mess, the disruption. And almost immediately, one question comes up:
Will my insurance policy cover this?
The honest answer is: sometimes.
Whether insurance pays or denies always comes down to why the backup happened.
We’ve worked with homeowners across Island, King, Skagit, and Snohomish Counties since 2017, bringing years of hands-on septic experience and a deep understanding of how septic systems actually fail and how insurance companies evaluate those failures.
To explain how insurance really looks at sewage and septic backups, we’ll lean heavily on real-world experience from our co-founder and general manager, Art Nikolin, who has seen these claims play out firsthand.
To explain how insurance really looks at sewage and septic backups, we’ll lean heavily on real-world experience from our co-founder and general manager, Art Nikolin, who has seen these claims play out firsthand.
Insurance Doesn’t Cover “Septic Systems.” It Covers Accidents
This is the most important thing for homeowners to understand.
Insurance policies are generally designed to cover sudden, accidental damage, not long-term wear, neglect, or maintenance-related failures. When an insurance company evaluates a septic or sewage backup claim, the conversation almost always comes down to one question:
Was this caused by an accident, or by lack of maintenance?
Art explains it this way:
“Every time we work with insurance, it turns into the same question. Was this negligence, or was it an accident? And what I see most often is that insurance companies will try to push it toward lack of maintenance.”
A simple comparison helps make this clearer.
If a tree falls on your roof and punches a hole through it, insurance will usually cover the damage. But if your roof starts leaking because it’s 25 years old and was never replaced, insurance will likely deny the claim.
Septic systems are treated the same way.
Insurance policies are generally designed to cover sudden, accidental damage, not long-term wear, neglect, or maintenance-related failures. When an insurance company evaluates a septic or sewage backup claim, the conversation almost always comes down to one question:
Was this caused by an accident, or by lack of maintenance?
Art explains it this way:
“Every time we work with insurance, it turns into the same question. Was this negligence, or was it an accident? And what I see most often is that insurance companies will try to push it toward lack of maintenance.”
A simple comparison helps make this clearer.
If a tree falls on your roof and punches a hole through it, insurance will usually cover the damage. But if your roof starts leaking because it’s 25 years old and was never replaced, insurance will likely deny the claim.
Septic systems are treated the same way.
Septic Situations Insurance Often Covers
While every policy is different, there are septic-related scenarios that insurance companies are more likely to cover because they qualify as sudden, accidental damage.
These often include:
Art recalls:
“The few systems I’ve always seen covered were things like a tree falling and uprooting the system. I even remember one where a dog dug up part of the system.”
In these situations, the damage is clearly tied to a specific, unexpected event, not something that developed slowly over time.
These often include:
- A tree falling or uprooting part of the septic system or drain field
- Vandalism that damages septic components
- Rare but sudden external events that physically damage the system
Art recalls:
“The few systems I’ve always seen covered were things like a tree falling and uprooting the system. I even remember one where a dog dug up part of the system.”
In these situations, the damage is clearly tied to a specific, unexpected event, not something that developed slowly over time.
Septic Issues That Are Commonly Denied
On the other hand, insurance companies almost always deny claims tied to gradual system failure or missing maintenance.
These usually include:
From an insurer’s perspective, these are not accidents. They’re preventable issues tied to system health and upkeep.
These usually include:
- Clogged or failing drain fields
- Pump failures due to age or wear
- Systems overloaded beyond what they were designed for
- Backups linked to skipped inspections or pumping
From an insurer’s perspective, these are not accidents. They’re preventable issues tied to system health and upkeep.
A Real Case: When Insurance Paid Some, But Not Everything
One of the clearest examples of how insurance evaluates septic claims comes from a case Art remembers very clearly, because of how long and complicated it became.
“I had a system that turned out to be kind of a hybrid case. The homeowner had issues due to lack of maintenance that weren’t being taken care of. Then they had a Douglas fir next to the system that fell over and tore up chunks of the drain field.”
What followed was a long and frustrating process.
The homeowner attempted to go through insurance. At the same time, the local health department became involved because there was surfacing effluent (wastewater coming up to the ground surface).
“It went back and forth for about 14 months. Insurance was involved. The health department was involved. The homeowner was basically stuck footing the bill for pumpings to avoid getting their home red taped while the claim was being resolved. because they thought insurance was going to pay for everything.”
Eventually, a decision was made.
“Insurance covered the repairs to the drain field where the tree roots tore things up. But the rest wasn’t covered. The pump issues and the clogged drain field still had to be handled by the homeowner.”
In the end, the outcome was roughly a 50/50 split. The accident-related damage was covered. The maintenance-related failures were not.
This kind of partial approval is extremely common in septic-related insurance claims.
“I had a system that turned out to be kind of a hybrid case. The homeowner had issues due to lack of maintenance that weren’t being taken care of. Then they had a Douglas fir next to the system that fell over and tore up chunks of the drain field.”
What followed was a long and frustrating process.
The homeowner attempted to go through insurance. At the same time, the local health department became involved because there was surfacing effluent (wastewater coming up to the ground surface).
“It went back and forth for about 14 months. Insurance was involved. The health department was involved. The homeowner was basically stuck footing the bill for pumpings to avoid getting their home red taped while the claim was being resolved. because they thought insurance was going to pay for everything.”
Eventually, a decision was made.
“Insurance covered the repairs to the drain field where the tree roots tore things up. But the rest wasn’t covered. The pump issues and the clogged drain field still had to be handled by the homeowner.”
In the end, the outcome was roughly a 50/50 split. The accident-related damage was covered. The maintenance-related failures were not.
This kind of partial approval is extremely common in septic-related insurance claims.
The Words That Decide Claims: “Sudden,” “Accidental,” and “Maintenance”
When insurance adjusters evaluate septic backups, certain policy terms matter more than homeowners realize.
Most decisions hinge on language like:
If a backup can be tied to a specific event such as a fallen tree, it may qualify. If it’s tied to system health over time, insurers typically classify it as a maintenance issue.
This is why documentation and maintenance history matter so much.
Most decisions hinge on language like:
- “Sudden and accidental damage”
- “Direct physical loss”
- Exclusions for wear, deterioration, or lack of maintenance
If a backup can be tied to a specific event such as a fallen tree, it may qualify. If it’s tied to system health over time, insurers typically classify it as a maintenance issue.
This is why documentation and maintenance history matter so much.
Backup Coverage: The Add-On Many Homeowners Don’t Know They Have (or Need)
Some homeowners have extra insurance coverage that helps pay for damage when sewage or wastewater backs up into their home.
This coverage can:
However, this type of coverage is often optional and varies widely between insurance policies. Many homeowners don’t realize whether they have one until after a backup occurs.
Knowing what coverage you have before an emergency makes a major difference.
This coverage can:
- Expand protection for certain types of backups
- Help pay for cleanup or repairs
- Set specific coverage caps for backup-related damage
However, this type of coverage is often optional and varies widely between insurance policies. Many homeowners don’t realize whether they have one until after a backup occurs.
Knowing what coverage you have before an emergency makes a major difference.
What Homeowners Need to Support
a Septic Insurance Claim
a Septic Insurance Claim
If you are filing a claim related to a septic or sewage backup, documentation becomes your strongest tool.
Insurance companies commonly ask for:
In Washington State, most septic systems are required to be inspected annually under guidelines set by the Washington State Department of Health. Missing inspection records often make it harder to prove that a failure was truly accidental.
Insurance companies commonly ask for:
- Photos or videos of the damage (when safe to capture)
- A clear timeline of when the issue started
- Septic pumping and inspection records
- Repair invoices and service history
- Evidence of any external event (storms, fallen trees, impact damage)
- A professional assessment from licensed septic professionals
In Washington State, most septic systems are required to be inspected annually under guidelines set by the Washington State Department of Health. Missing inspection records often make it harder to prove that a failure was truly accidental.
Typical Payout Expectations: Why Septic Claims Are Often Partial
As the Douglas fir case mentioned earlier in this article shows, septic insurance companies lean towards denial.
Many policies:
It’s common for insurance to pay for part of the work while denying others, especially when both accidental damage and maintenance issues are involved.
Many policies:
- Cap payouts for backup-related damage
- Cover cleanup but not system components
- Cover specific damaged sections, not full replacements
It’s common for insurance to pay for part of the work while denying others, especially when both accidental damage and maintenance issues are involved.
Why Septic Insurance Claims Can Take So Long
Septic-related claims often move slower than homeowners expect.
That’s because they usually involve:
As Art’s 14-month example shows, waiting on insurance does not pause regulatory responsibilities. Surfacing effluent and failing systems still need to be addressed, regardless of how long a claim takes.
That’s because they usually involve:
- Determining the exact cause of failure
- Reviewing long-term maintenance history
- Environmental and health department requirements
- Multiple inspections and approvals
As Art’s 14-month example shows, waiting on insurance does not pause regulatory responsibilities. Surfacing effluent and failing systems still need to be addressed, regardless of how long a claim takes.
What to Do If You’re Dealing With a Backup Right Now
If you’re facing an active sewage or septic backup:
Fast, professional assessment helps protect your home and clarifies what documentation may be needed if insurance becomes involved.
- Reduce or stop water use where possible
- Keep people and pets away from affected areas
- Document conditions if it’s safe to do so
- Contact licensed septic professionals promptly
Fast, professional assessment helps protect your home and clarifies what documentation may be needed if insurance becomes involved.
The Real Takeaway: Prevention Is the Best Insurance Strategy
So, will your insurance policy cover a sewage backup?
If the cause is sudden and accidental, you may have a path forward.
If the cause is tied to maintenance, insurance will likely deny it.
The best way to protect yourself is proactive care:
At Septic Solutions LLC, we don’t just respond to emergencies. We help homeowners maintain the long-term health of their systems, so backups are less likely to happen in the first place.
If you’re in Island, King, Skagit, or Snohomish Counties and have questions about your septic system, inspections, or emergency service, our licensed team is available 24/7, with an average estimated arrival time in under 12 hours.
Because when septic problems happen, waiting days is not an option. And understanding the cause can make all the difference.
If the cause is sudden and accidental, you may have a path forward.
If the cause is tied to maintenance, insurance will likely deny it.
The best way to protect yourself is proactive care:
- Annual inspections
- Routine septic pumping
- Addressing small issues before they become emergencies
At Septic Solutions LLC, we don’t just respond to emergencies. We help homeowners maintain the long-term health of their systems, so backups are less likely to happen in the first place.
If you’re in Island, King, Skagit, or Snohomish Counties and have questions about your septic system, inspections, or emergency service, our licensed team is available 24/7, with an average estimated arrival time in under 12 hours.
Because when septic problems happen, waiting days is not an option. And understanding the cause can make all the difference.